Conducting a disciplinary hearing is a critical process for any organisation facing employee misconduct or performance issues.
It ensures fairness, compliance with employment law, and maintains a positive workplace culture.
At Emberscale, we specialise in outsourcing business solutions, including comprehensive HR support to guide you through these challenging situations.
In this guide, we’ll explore how to conduct a disciplinary hearing step by step, drawing on best practices to help you navigate it effectively.
Whether you’re a small business owner or an HR manager, understanding this process can prevent costly disputes and foster trust within your team.
Understanding the Purpose of a Disciplinary Hearing
A disciplinary hearing serves as a formal opportunity to address concerns about an employee’s behaviour or performance.
It allows both parties to present their sides, ensuring decisions are based on facts rather than assumptions.
In the UK, under the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures, employers must follow a fair process to avoid unfair dismissal claims.
Failing to do so can lead to tribunal awards that are substantially high.
The goal is not just punishment, but resolution—aiming to correct issues and support employee improvement where possible.
By handling it professionally, you demonstrate your commitment to equity, which can boost morale across the organisation.
Remember, every hearing is unique, influenced by the specifics of the allegation, company policy, and legal context.
Preparing for the Disciplinary Hearing
Preparation is the foundation of a successful disciplinary hearing.
Start by reviewing all relevant documentation, such as performance records, witness statements, and previous warnings.
Gather evidence objectively to build a clear case, ensuring it’s accurate and up to date.
Appoint an impartial chairperson—ideally someone not directly involved in the incident—to oversee the proceedings.
This person should be trained in employment law to maintain neutrality.
Consider logistical aspects, like a private room free from interruptions, and arrange for note-taking to create an accurate record.
Anticipate potential questions or defences by role-playing scenarios with your team.
Thorough preparation not only strengthens your position but also respects the employee’s right to a fair hearing.
Notifying the Employee and Setting Expectations
Clear notification sets the tone for transparency in how to conduct a disciplinary hearing.
When inviting an employee to a disciplinary hearing, ensure the process is fair, transparent, and compliant with UK employment law, particularly the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
Provide written notice in good time before the hearing, allowing reasonable preparation time—typically at least 48 hours as a minimum, though 3-5 working days is recommended for most cases to account for evidence review and arranging accompaniment.
For more serious allegations, extend this to 5-7 days to avoid challenges on procedural fairness.
Your invitation letter should outline the alleged misconduct or performance issue in specific terms, avoiding vague language.
Include supporting evidence from the investigation, any other information to be discussed, and copies of all relevant documents.
Specify the date, time, and location (or virtual details if applicable) of the hearing.
Inform them of their statutory right to bring a companion, such as a work colleague, trade union representative, or official employed by a trade union.
The employee must make a reasonable request for the companion, including the person’s name and role, giving enough time for them to prepare by reviewing materials.
Employers aren’t required to allow non-standard companions like family members, but may do so at discretion, and must make reasonable adjustments under equality laws for disabled employees, such as permitting a support worker.
Encourage them to submit any response or additional evidence beforehand, and inform them they may request witnesses be called, provided good notice is given.
Specify the hearing’s format, expected duration, and any potential outcomes, such as warnings or dismissal.
Acas provides free letter templates to help structure this notification effectively.
This step complies with UK employment regulations and helps de-escalate tensions by showing respect for due process.
Follow up with a phone call to confirm receipt and address immediate queries, building rapport before the meeting.
If the employee is unable to attend due to illness or other reasons, rearrange promptly while considering alternatives like a different time or format; proceeding without them requires careful justification and an opportunity for written input.
Deliver this notice via a method that confirms receipt—such as email with read receipt or recorded post—further demonstrates good faith.
By prioritising these elements in how to conduct a disciplinary hearing, you minimise tribunal risks, where failure to give adequate notice or comply with the Acas Code could lead to uplifts in compensation awards of up to 25%.
Effective notification ensures the employee feels heard from the outset, reducing the likelihood of appeals later.
Conducting the Hearing Itself
When it’s time to hold the hearing, begin with introductions to ease any initial discomfort.
The chairperson should explain the process, reiterate confidentiality, and confirm the employee’s companion’s role.
Present the allegations methodically, sharing evidence and allowing questions at each stage.
Give the employee ample time to respond, probing gently for clarification without interruption.
Listen actively, noting body language and tone to gauge understanding.
If new information emerges, consider adjourning to investigate further—fairness demands this flexibility.
Keep discussions focused on facts, steering away from personal attacks or unrelated matters.
Document everything verbatim where possible, as this record will be invaluable for appeals or legal reviews.
End the session by outlining next steps, such as deliberation time, to provide closure.
Mastering how to conduct a disciplinary hearing in this structured way upholds organisational integrity.
Making the Decision Post-Hearing
After the hearing, deliberate carefully before deciding on outcomes.
Review all evidence, responses, and notes with any advisors, weighing mitigating factors like length of service or remorse.
Decisions should align with your disciplinary policy—ranging from verbal warnings to dismissal.
Consider alternatives like additional training or performance plans if improvement seems feasible.
Communicate the outcome in writing within a reasonable timeframe, typically five working days.
Explain the rationale clearly, referencing specific evidence, and detail any appeal rights.
If dismissal is the result, outline notice periods and final pay arrangements.
This phase is pivotal in demonstrating consistency across cases, which tribunals scrutinise closely.
A well-reasoned decision not only resolves the issue but also reinforces your company’s values.
Following Up After the Disciplinary Hearing
Post-hearing follow-up ensures the process leads to positive change.
Schedule a review meeting to monitor progress if a warning or improvement plan is issued.
Provide resources, such as training, to support the employee’s development.
Update HR records accurately and inform relevant stakeholders on a need-to-know basis.
If an appeal is lodged, handle it promptly with a higher-level reviewer.
Reflect on the process internally—what went well, and what could improve for next time?
This continuous learning approach strengthens your overall HR framework.
By closing the loop effectively, you turn a potentially divisive event into an opportunity for growth.
Remember, how to conduct a disciplinary hearing extends beyond the meeting itself; it’s about sustained fairness.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid in Disciplinary Hearings
Even experienced managers can stumble in disciplinary hearings.
One frequent error is rushing preparation, leading to incomplete evidence and biased perceptions.
Another is failing to remain impartial, which erodes trust and invites legal challenges.
Overlooking the employee’s right to accompaniment can invalidate the process entirely.
Emotional responses—such as raising voices—undermine professionalism and escalate conflicts.
Ignoring cultural or personal contexts in responses may result in unfair judgements.
Not documenting thoroughly risks disputes over what was said.
Delaying decisions prolongs uncertainty, harming productivity.
By anticipating these pitfalls, you can conduct hearings that are robust and defensible.
Proactive avoidance keeps your organisation compliant and respected.
How Emberscale Can Support Your HR Needs
At Emberscale, we understand the complexities of managing disciplinary matters in a fast-paced business environment.
As specialists in outsourcing business solutions for B2B services, we offer tailored support to streamline your processes.
HR Services
Our HR services encompass compliance advisory, policy development, and employee relations management.
We handle everything from onboarding to exit processes, ensuring adherence to UK employment law.
This proactive approach substantially reduces tribunal exposure by embedding best practices.
Custom audits identify gaps, while ongoing support keeps your team aligned.
Recruitment
Emberscale’s recruitment solutions deliver efficient talent acquisition without the overheads.
We source, screen, and onboard candidates tailored to your needs.
Our methods prioritise diversity and fairness, minimising bias claims.
Partnering with us means accessing a vetted pool, faster than in-house efforts.
Sales Training
Elevate your team’s performance through our bespoke sales training programmes.
We cover negotiation, objection handling, and closing techniques.
Delivered via workshops or online modules, these sessions boost revenue while fostering ethical selling.
Results include higher close rates and reduced compliance risks in client interactions.
Outsourced Sales
For scalable growth, our outsourced sales teams manage lead generation to deal closure.
We integrate seamlessly, using data-driven strategies for optimal ROI.
This model proves substantially cheaper than building internal squads.
Track progress with real-time dashboards, ensuring alignment with your goals.
SEO Services
Enhance visibility with our SEO services, optimised for search engines and generative AI.
We conduct audits, keyword research, and content strategies.
On-page tweaks and link-building drive organic traffic affordably.
Expect sustained rankings without the expertise burden.
Video Production
Our video production crafts compelling narratives for marketing and training.
From script to final edit, we produce high-quality content.
Use videos for employee inductions or sales pitches to engage audiences.
This visual edge strengthens branding while supporting internal communications.
Contact Emberscale
With Emberscale, you gain a partner dedicated to your success across these vital areas.
Contact us today for a free consultation to assess your needs.
UK: 020 3432 2025
US: 888-400-9953
Conclusion: Mastering How to Conduct a Disciplinary Hearing
Conducting a disciplinary hearing doesn’t have to be daunting when approached methodically.
By following these steps—from preparation to follow-up—you ensure fairness, legality, and effectiveness.
At Emberscale, we’re here to outsource the expertise you need, letting you focus on what you do best.
Embrace this process as a tool for stronger teams and smoother operations.
Ready to enhance your HR strategy?
Reach out via our contact numbers above or alternatively click here to send us your query.
Frequently Asked Questions on How to Conduct a Disciplinary Hearing
Q: What should be included in the invitation to a disciplinary hearing?
A: The invitation must be in writing and include the allegations in specific terms, copies of evidence, the date, time, and location of the hearing, the employee’s right to accompaniment, and potential outcomes like warnings or dismissal.
Provide at least 48 hours’ notice, ideally 3-5 working days, and use Acas templates for structure.
This ensures compliance and fairness, reducing appeal risks.
Q: Who can accompany an employee to a disciplinary hearing?
A: The employee has the right to bring a work colleague, trade union representative, or union official.
They must request this reasonably in advance, including the companion’s details.
Employers should allow reasonable adjustments for disabled employees, but aren’t obligated for family or external lawyers unless specified.
This supports natural justice under the Acas Code.
Q: Can the same person conduct the investigation and the disciplinary hearing?
A: It’s best practice to use different people for each stage to avoid bias, as recommended by Acas guidance on workplace investigations.
A manager who witnessed the incident should not chair the hearing, as it could be seen as unfair.
Appointing an impartial chairperson strengthens the process and defends against tribunal claims.
Q: What key questions should you ask during a disciplinary hearing?
A: Focus on clarifying allegations, such as: “Can you explain your version of events?” “Do you accept the misconduct?” and “What mitigating factors apply?”
Allow the employee to present evidence and witnesses, then probe responses without leading.
These questions ensure thoroughness and give both sides a fair opportunity.
Q: What happens if an employee doesn’t attend the disciplinary hearing?
A: Rearrange the hearing promptly if there’s a valid reason like illness, offering alternatives such as a different date or virtual format.
If they refuse without justification, you may proceed in their absence but must allow written submissions and justify the decision carefully.
This maintains procedural fairness per Acas guidelines.
